Harley Spiller Collection
The Harley J Spiller collection includes more than 10,000 Chinese food artifacts includes menus from around the world. The UTSC library is digitizing the collection, which will make it more accessible to both scholars and a general audience. (Photos by Ken Jones)
Tuesday, February 9 - 2016
Don Campbell

A massive collection of Chinese food artifacts recently acquired by U of T Scarborough will help scholars explore the important role food culture has played in the immigrant experience throughout North America.

“This collection really puts us on the map as an important destination for those interested in studying not only food but the role of migration and food,” says Professor Dan Bender, director of UTSC’s Culinaria Research Centre.

“The menus in particular tell a story that is more than just a list of items for sale. It’s a conversation taking place between the cook, waiter and owner with the customer. It’s evidence of a relationship, one that shows signs of respect but also fraught with anxiety and tension.”

Consisting of 10,000 items, mostly Chinese menus collected by Harley J Spiller between 1981 and 2009, the collection also contains documents, photographs and other artifacts. The collection includes menus from all 50 U.S. States, across Canada and the world, while in 2005 was recognized by the Guinness World Records as the largest of its kind.

The collection is currently being digitized by the UTSC library and will likely be used to map out the development of Chinese food culture in North America, notes Bender. The menus, especially the earlier ones, also highlight an important cultural and economic legacy left by Chinese who immigrated to North America.

“By opening restaurants these immigrants were exercising mobility rights in a society that officially excluded them,” he says.

They were also communicating aspects of their cultural traditions to a new society, and in some cases doing it in very creative ways, he adds. Pointing to dishes developed specifically to cater to North American customers such as Chop Suey or Egg Fu Yung, he notes there’s evidence of an elaborate cultural give and take.

“In some ways it’s a subtle jibe, like saying ‘you may think this is what Chinese culture is about,’ but only permitting them to see a small slice that’s been carefully crafted.” 

The oldest menu in the collection, dated September 13, 1896, is believed to have been used at a luncheon in New York honouring Chinese statesman Li hongzhang, while there are about 1,000 menus pre-dating 1960. Some menus have elaborate and colourful illustrations on the cover. In addition to menus there are chopsticks, postcards, plastic spoons and even a toy wok. There’s also photographs and postcards of Chinese food and restaurants from around the world.

The UTSC library is digitizing the collection in order to make it more accessible to scholars and a general audience, says Chief Librarian Victoria Owen.

“There are many things that can be gleaned from the items including prices, locale, change in menus, the graphics and then you can pinpoint them more closely in time,” she told Yahoo News Canada

If recent media stories about the collection like the Toronto Star and CBC Radio’s As it Happens are any indication, the collection will also garner interest from a general audience as well. It’s something that pleases the man who created the collection in the first place.

“UTSC offered a permanent home for my collection and in the hands of the library and archivists will be seen by more people,” said Spiller. “It’s nice to know it will not only be put to good academic use, but it also will be enjoyed for years to come.”