A new U of T study is challenging our definition of what makes a planet hospitable, finding that snowball planets may harbour the conditions for life to exist.
“When we think of a habitable planet, we tend to imagine a relatively warm place like Earth,” says Adiv Paradise, a PhD candidate in the Department of Astronomy and Astrophysics and lead author of the study.
“What our research suggests is that snowball planets — that is, those with oceans that are completely covered in sea ice — shouldn’t be excluded as being inhospitable to life.”
For the study, Paradise and his colleagues, including supervisor Kristen Menou, associate professor in the Department of Physical and Environmental Sciences and the Centre for Planetary Sciences, ran thousands of three-dimensional computer simulations of planets in the inner habitable zone with Earth-like climates.
What they found is that if there are areas of dark, bare ground that receive enough sunlight, those regions can be warm enough for liquid water and life, without causing the ice to retreat.
“These planets may get a similar amount of light as Earth and the temperature will be above freezing, but unlike Earth, they are trapped in a snowball state where the rest of the planet remains frozen.”
According to geological evidence, Earth has entered into a snowball state at least twice, the most recent was about a billion years ago, and it lasted for tens of millions of years.
What likely triggered Earth’s emergence from its snowball state was the large accumulation of carbon dioxide (CO2) in the atmosphere released mostly by volcanoes over millions of years. Once out of snowball, rain triggered by warming temperatures removed CO2 out of the air where it was absorbed in rocks and soil. This balanced the CO2 being added by volcanoes and helped stabilize warm conditions globally.
With a permanent snowball planet, CO2 is being removed faster than the rate at which it’s being put back through volcanoes. This can cause a planet to enter snowball, but it will only get locked into that state if the rate at which CO2 is removed (through rainfall on those patches of warm land) can balance the rate at which volcanoes are putting it back.
“What we’re arguing here is that we shouldn’t write off snowball planets as being inhospitable to life,” Paradise says.
“Some of the habitable planets we discover are going to be quite different from ours in terms of weather and climate, so we should reconcile ourselves to that fact.”
The study, which is published in the Journal of Geophysical Research: Planets, received funding from Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (NSERC).
There’s no way to know what percentage of exoplanets (those outside our solar system) are in a snowball state. As Paradise points out, the only way to find out at the moment would be to physically observe them and the telescopes available to us aren’t powerful enough.
He says another lingering question is how much CO2 is on an average planet, and how volcanically active the average planet is compared to Earth.
“If most planets are less volcanically active than Earth, you might expect a significant fraction of them to be in snowball. At the same time, if Earth is less volcanically active than most, you’d expect snowball planets to be rare.”
As for what life on these snowball planets may look like, Paradise says it would most likely be aquatic. The Earth descended into a snowball state right after life first began to emerge, and it was entirely aquatic.
“With these snowball planets that we’re looking at, the ocean waters beneath the ice likely wouldn’t be radically different from the waters in the Arctic Ocean on Earth,” Paradise says.